This tiny little bakery on the Upper West Side has the reputation of turning out one of the best cookies in New York City. Even on a late Sunday afternoon, half an hour before closing, there was a long line out its door! Thankfully the line moved quickly. The minute I stepped into the bakery, I was overwhelmed (in a good way) by the aroma of the freshly baked cookies.
Even though I had the good intention of just getting 1 cookie, somehow I walked out of the store with two =P. The cookies are absolutely divine!! It's shaped more like a mount than a flat disk. A mount of warm, gooey, goodness! My photos don't do the cookies justice at all.
The saltiness of the peanut butter chip really balanced out the sweetness of the chocolate nicely. That said, I really love the chocolate chocolate chip cookie as well.
The only thing missing was a tall glass of milk!
Verdict: AAA. Live up to the hype. It's possibility the best cookies that I have ever had…or at least in recent memory.
167 West 74th Street (@Columbus Street)